Top St. Augustine Neighborhoods to Call Home

St. Augustine, Florida, is one of the nation's most treasured gems, celebrated not only as the oldest city in the United States but also as a popular destination for both locals and visitors. The city boasts an array of unique neighborhoods, each with its distinct charm, attractions, and historical significance. Whether you're a lifelong resident or new to the area, these neighborhoods in St. Augustine are well worth exploring.

Historic Downtown

At the heart of St. Augustine lies Historic Downtown, the epicenter of the city's dining, shopping, hotels, and attractions. This area, the oldest part of the city, features buildings dating back to the 1700s. Its walkable streets are lined with beautiful churches, museums, and venues for live music. From the bayfront, you can enjoy stunning views of Matanzas Bay or take a leisurely stroll along the Matanzas River. Historic Downtown is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, along with more than twenty other locations within the neighborhood.

King Street District

King Street District is known for its unique and eclectic shopping experience. This area, with architecture from the early 1900s, was once a bustling business district. Today, it offers a variety of restaurants and shops, from vintage furniture stores to seafaring essentials. Visitors can mark their trip with a tattoo or enjoy a meal at one of the family-owned restaurants. With free parking and an array of retail shops, breweries, and eateries, King Street District is a must-visit.

Lincolnville

Although technically part of the Historic District, Lincolnville stands out as a gem of its own. Founded after the Civil War, it became home to many prominent Black professionals and business owners. Today, Lincolnville's Victorian homes often feature plaques honoring residents who made significant contributions to the community and the nation. The neighborhood offers charming bed and breakfasts, cafes, and easy access to the waterfront Plaza de la Constitucion.

Uptown

Adjacent to Historic Downtown, Uptown St. Augustine is renowned for its historic properties, boutiques, art galleries, and antique stores. Highlights include The Fountain of Youth Archaeological Park, the site of the first Spanish settlement in the United States. A stroll through Uptown reveals architecture dating back to the 1800s, with many buildings listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The area is dotted with quaint restaurants and hotels, making it perfect for a leisurely walk.

Anastasia Island

Anastasia Island stretches fourteen miles long and one mile wide, bordered by the Atlantic Ocean and the Matanzas River. Known for its stunning beaches, the island also boasts numerous hotels, restaurants, and bars. Notable landmarks include the St. Augustine Lighthouse and the St. Augustine Amphitheatre, which hosts live music events. Anastasia Island is ideal for outdoor activities like surfing, kayaking, camping, and fishing.

World Golf Village

Built in the 1990s by the PGA, World Golf Village includes the World Golf Hall of Fame. The neighborhood features large country homes, expansive lands, and top-tier golf courses such as King & Bear and Slammer & Squire. Beyond golf, visitors can enjoy spas, restaurants, event venues, and an IMAX theater. Golfers can also take advantage of the clubs' extensive amenities.